TRW & Co · Refusals, appeals and challenges
Human rights claims in UK immigration law

A human rights claim is a claim that removal, or refusal of entry, would breach your Convention rights. Most are Article 8 family or private life claims, made on forms such as FLR(FP). Refusal usually carries a right of appeal, unless the claim is certified. The strongest claims meet the Immigration Rules; exceptional circumstances are the fallback.
Key pointThe form and the framing decide whether a refusal can be appealed at all, so make the claim expressly and on the right form.
At a glance
Definition
A claim to the Home Office that removal or refusal of entry breaches s.6 Human Rights Act 1998 (s.113 NIAA 2002).
Main rights
Article 8 (private and family life) and Article 3 (ill-treatment).
Forms
FLR(FP) for family or private life; FLR(HRO) for other human rights claims.
Fees
£1,407 in-country plus IHS as at November 2026; fee waiver available if destitute.
On refusal
Usually a right of appeal; certified claims need judicial review.
Swipe or scroll →
What a human rights claim is in UK immigration law
In UK immigration law, a human rights claim is a claim to the Home Office that removing you from the UK, requiring you to leave, or refusing you entry would breach your rights under the European Convention on Human Rights, as given effect by the Human Rights Act 1998. The definition is statutory: section 113 of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002 says the claim must be made to the Secretary of State "at a place designated" by her, which in practice means on the right form or in the right process.
The label matters because of what follows a refusal. Under section 82 of the same Act, refusal of a human rights claim carries a right of appeal to the First-tier Tribunal. Most refusals of ordinary visa applications do not. Whether your application is a human rights claim (UK practice treats family and private life applications this way) therefore decides whether a judge will ever look at your case.
This guide explains how a human rights application is framed, made and decided, and where it can go wrong. For representation, see our human rights immigration solicitors page.
Which Convention rights are engaged
Section 6 of the Human Rights Act 1998 makes it unlawful for a public authority, including the Home Office, to act incompatibly with a Convention right. The rights themselves are set out in Schedule 1 to the Act. In immigration cases two dominate.
Article 8: private and family life
Everyone has the right to respect for private and family life, home and correspondence. Interference must be in accordance with the law and necessary for a listed aim, such as the economic well-being of the country.
Article 3: ill-treatment
No one shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. The right is absolute, and it arises in protection and some serious medical cases.
Other articles
Articles 2 (life), 4 (slavery) and 5 (liberty) arise less often, usually alongside asylum, trafficking or detention issues.
Protection claims are separate
A claim that removal would breach the Refugee Convention is a protection claim, not a human rights claim, though the two are often made together.
Article 8 is a qualified right, so the question is almost always whether refusal is a proportionate interference. Article 3 is absolute, so the question is whether the risk of ill-treatment meets the high threshold. The rest of this guide concentrates on the Article 8 claim, which is by far the most common human rights claim UK decision-makers see.
Medical cases sit between the two. A serious illness can support an Article 8 claim (because of its effect on private life and on family members who provide care) and, in the most severe cases, an Article 3 claim. The thresholds differ, and so does the evidence: an Article 3 medical claim needs specialist evidence about treatment availability and the consequences of removal, not only a diagnosis. Decide early which right the human rights application really rests on, and say so.
How an Article 8 claim is decided
The Home Office deals with Article 8 in two layers. The first is the Immigration Rules: Appendix FM for partners, parents and children, and Appendix Private Life for people relying on their life in the UK. If the Rules are met, the human rights application is usually granted on that basis. If they are not, the decision-maker must go on to consider Article 8 outside the specific requirements.
For family cases, paragraph GEN.3.2 of Appendix FM requires the decision-maker to consider whether there are exceptional circumstances that would make refusal a breach of Article 8 because it "would result in unjustifiably harsh consequences" for the applicant, their partner, a relevant child or another affected family member. GEN.3.3 requires the best interests of any relevant child to be taken into account as a primary consideration. For private life cases, PL 8.1 of Appendix Private Life imposes a parallel duty to check that refusal would not breach Article 8.
Meeting the Rules is the strongest Article 8 claim; arguing "exceptional circumstances" is the fallback, not the plan.
A successful Article 8 claim outside the Rules usually leads to permission on a 10-year route to settlement, rather than the 5-year route available to those who meet the Rules in full. That difference in timing is one reason to build the human rights application around the Rules wherever possible. See our guide to the ten-year partner route for how that works for couples.
Example: one family, two ways to frame the Article 8 claim
Example (hypothetical): a Nigerian national has lived in Croydon for nine years, first as a student and then without leave. He has a British partner and a stepdaughter aged ten who has lived in the UK all her life. His partner's earnings are below the £29,000 minimum income requirement, so the 5-year partner route under Appendix FM is not available.
Framed narrowly, his human rights application relies on his own nine years of private life, which section 117B(4) and (5) say should carry little weight because it was built while unlawful or precarious. Framed properly, it is a family life Article 8 claim centred on his partner and on a qualifying child, supported by school and welfare evidence, and argued under GEN.3.2 and section 117B(6). The second framing addresses the questions the decision-maker must actually answer. Neither framing guarantees a grant; the example shows why the structure of the claim matters.
Private life: the residence thresholds
Appendix Private Life sets bright-line residence tests. Continuous residence may include time with or without permission (PL 7.1), but it excludes time in prison following a conviction, and it is broken by 550 days or more of absence (PL 7.3).
| Applicant | Requirement | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Child under 18 | At least 7 years' continuous residence, and not reasonable to expect the child to leave the UK | PL 3.1 |
| Young adult aged 18 to 24 who arrived before 18 | At least half their life continuously resident in the UK | PL 4.1 |
| Adult | More than 20 years' continuous residence | PL 5.1(a) |
| Adult (alternative) | Very significant obstacles to integration in the country of return | PL 5.1(b) |
| Anyone not meeting the above | Refusal must not breach Article 8 on private life grounds | PL 8.1 |
For a successful private life human rights application, grants are normally for 30 months at a time, and settlement on this route generally follows 10 years, with carve-outs for illegal entry and suitability. A child born in the UK who has lived here continuously for 7 years may qualify for immediate settlement. Our guide to the private life route covers extensions and settlement in detail.

The public interest: Part 5A of the 2002 Act
Whenever a court or tribunal decides whether an immigration decision breaches Article 8, section 117A requires it to have regard to the public interest considerations in section 117B (and, in deportation cases, section 117C). The Home Office applies the same framework in its decisions.
- The maintenance of effective immigration controls is in the public interest
- It is in the public interest that people who enter or remain can speak English
- It is in the public interest that people are financially independent
- Little weight should be given to a private life, or a relationship with a qualifying partner, formed while in the UK unlawfully
- Little weight should be given to a private life formed while immigration status was precarious
- For a person not liable to deportation, the public interest does not require removal where there is a genuine and subsisting parental relationship with a qualifying child and it would not be reasonable to expect the child to leave
In practice this means evidence of English ability and financial independence helps an Article 8 claim, even where they are not strict requirements, and it means the strongest private life claims often rest on a long period of lawful residence or on the position of a qualifying child. For people with criminal convictions, section 117C and the deportation framework apply instead; see our deportation solicitors page.
Making a human rights claim: UK forms, fees and evidence
Because section 113 requires a human rights claim to be made at a designated place, the form matters: an Article 8 claim raised informally in a letter may not count as a claim at all. In the UK, the Home Office directs applicants to these forms:
- Choose the right form. FLR(FP) covers family life as a partner or parent on the 10-year route, dependent children, private life and leave outside the Rules on family or private life grounds. FLR(HRO) covers other human rights claims and leave outside the Rules. The Home Office further submissions guidance points to FLR(O) for medical grounds.
- Check the fee or a waiver. The in-country fee shown in the Home Office fee table was £1,407 per applicant as at November 2026, plus the Immigration Health Surcharge (£1,035 a year; £2,587.50 for a 30-month grant). If you are destitute, apply for a fee waiver first: the forms say the waiver must come before the application.
- Build the evidence. Prove each fact the Rules require, then add the Article 8 material: relationships, children's schooling and welfare, health, length and quality of residence, and obstacles to life abroad.
- Write a clear covering statement. Explain which Rule you meet, or why refusal would be disproportionate if you do not, with the evidence indexed.
- Keep status in mind. Applying before existing leave expires keeps section 3C leave running during the decision and any in-time appeal.
Evidence wins or loses an Article 8 claim. For relationships, show cohabitation and shared responsibilities over time, not only certificates. For children, include school attendance and reports, GP or health visitor records and, where the case turns on a child's welfare, an independent professional assessment. For private life, show the depth of ties: work history, community involvement, friendships and any health needs. For obstacles abroad, address language, family support, housing and work prospects in the country of return with specific evidence rather than general statements.
Outside the UK, a human rights claim is usually raised within an entry clearance application, for example a partner application that relies on exceptional circumstances. Section 113 includes claims that refusing entry would be unlawful, so a refusal can carry an appeal, but it must be brought from abroad.
Do not leave the human rights argument implicit. A one-line reference to "my family life" in a Skilled Worker application rarely turns it into a human rights claim. If Article 8 is genuinely engaged, make the claim on the right form with the evidence to support it.
Certification, section 120 and lost appeal rights
Three statutory tools can take away the appeal that a refused human rights claim would otherwise carry. Under section 94, the Home Office may certify a claim as "clearly unfounded", and section 94(3A) then bars any appeal. Under section 94B, some human rights claims can be certified so that the appeal must be brought from outside the UK. And under section 96, a later claim can be certified if it relies on a ground that could have been raised in an earlier appeal, or that should have been raised in response to a section 120 notice, without satisfactory reason.
The section 120 "one-stop" notice is the hinge. It requires you to set out all your reasons for staying and all grounds on which you should not be removed. Where your circumstances change afterwards, you must provide a supplementary statement as soon as reasonably practicable. Treat any section 120 notice as a deadline to put every Article 8 claim and other human rights point on the record. Certified decisions are usually challenged by judicial review, not appeal.
The practical lesson is to front-load the human rights claim. UK decision-makers are entitled to treat late-raised grounds with suspicion, and the statutory scheme penalises silence. If a family relationship, a health condition or a child's position might support an Article 8 claim, put it in the first human rights application or the first section 120 response, with evidence, rather than holding it back for a later stage.
After the decision
If the human rights application is granted
- Permission is usually for 30 months at a time
- Conditions are set out on the eVisa; check work and public funds conditions
- Apply to extend before expiry to keep continuous lawful residence
- Settlement typically after 10 years on the route, or 5 if the Rules are met in full on a 5-year route
If the human rights claim is refused
- A right of appeal to the First-tier Tribunal usually follows (s.82)
- Deadline: 14 days in the UK, 28 days from abroad
- If certified, consider judicial review promptly
- New evidence after appeal rights end goes through paragraph 353
If you appeal, our guide to the First-tier Tribunal immigration appeal explains the timetable and the appeal bundle. If an earlier claim failed and something significant has changed, our guide to fresh claims under paragraph 353 explains the test a renewed claim must meet.

Problems that sink human rights applications
Relying on exceptional circumstances when a Rule could be met
If you can meet Appendix FM or Appendix Private Life with better evidence, do that first. It is a more certain test and can lead to a shorter route to settlement.
Thin evidence about children
The best interests of a relevant child are a primary consideration. School reports, health records and letters from professionals carry far more weight than parents' assertions.
Ignoring the "precarious" rule
Private life built while on temporary visas attracts little weight under section 117B(5). Arguments need more than length of residence: focus on what makes this case different.
Breaking continuous residence
Absences totalling 550 days or more break continuous residence under PL 7.3. Reconstruct travel history from passports and records before applying.
Missing the suitability rules
Since 11 November 2025, family and private life routes apply Part Suitability. Convictions, including suspended sentences of 12 months or more for convictions from 22 March 2026, can lead to mandatory refusal.
Reform: what is law and what is proposed
In force now: Part Suitability applies to family and private life routes (since 11 November 2025), and families in the Family Returns Process can make Article 8 claims to Home Office staff without a fee (HC 584, from 8 October 2026). From 26 March 2027, applicants for settlement on routes including Private Life and Settlement Family Life will need English at B2 rather than B1; this is laid in the Rules (HC 1691) but not yet in effect.
Proposed, not law: the Immigration and Asylum Bill 2026 (Lords first reading 18 November 2026) would define family life in statute as normally immediate family, require overseas Article 8 claims to be brought by a UK-based sponsor and strengthen the public interest test, according to the Home Office Article 8 factsheet. Separately, the earned settlement policy announced on 2 November 2026 (CP 1707) says Family and Private Life permission would not qualify for its 3- or 5-year pathways, and that Article 8 time could not be combined with work or family time. Neither is in the Rules and no commencement date has been published.
Because settlement rules apply at the date of application, people currently on a human rights route should keep records of residence, earnings and English test results now. Treat the Bill and earned settlement as proposals until the Rules or an Act change.


Related routes and guides
Spouse visa
The 5-year partner route under Appendix FM.
Read the guideFamilyExceptional circumstances
GEN.3.2 and unjustifiably harsh consequences.
Read the guideRemediesPrivate life route
Appendix Private Life in detail.
Read the guideRemediesImmigration appeals
Representation at the tribunal.
Read the guideNext steps
Before making a human rights claim, UK or overseas, list every fact you rely on and match it to a Rule or to the Article 8 balance, then check your residence history and any convictions against the suitability rules. If you hold a refusal, note the date and whether it gives a right of appeal.
We usually start by testing whether the Rules can be met, because that is the most reliable footing for any Article 8 claim. To discuss a human rights claim, book a consultation.
Frequently asked questions
01Is every application a human rights claim?
No. Work, study and visit applications are not normally human rights claims, so refusals go to administrative review. Family and private life applications are usually treated as human rights claims.
02Can I make an Article 8 claim from outside the UK?
Yes, usually within an entry clearance application. Section 113 covers refusal of entry, so a refusal can be appealed, but only from abroad. The Immigration and Asylum Bill proposes that overseas claims be brought by a UK-based sponsor; that is not yet law.
03How long is permission granted for?
Normally 30 months at a time on the private life and 10-year family routes, with settlement generally after 10 years. Check current settlement rules before applying.
04Can I work while my human rights application is pending?
If you applied in time, section 3C extends your existing leave on its existing conditions. If you had no leave when you applied, section 3C does not help; take advice before starting any work.
05What is a fee waiver?
A request to apply without paying the fee because you are destitute or would become so. The FLR(FP) guidance says the waiver application must be made before the main application.
06Does a British child guarantee success?
No. Section 117B(6) says removal is not required where there is a genuine parental relationship with a qualifying child and it would not be reasonable to expect the child to leave, but the facts and the reasonableness question still have to be proved.
07What if my claim is certified as clearly unfounded?
There is no appeal. The certificate can be challenged by judicial review, which has strict time limits and usually starts with a pre-action letter.
Sources and official materials
- Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002, section 113 — Definition of a human rights claim
- Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002, section 117B — Article 8 public interest considerations
- Human Rights Act 1998, Schedule 1 — Text of Articles 3 and 8
- Immigration Rules: Appendix Private Life — Residence thresholds and grants
- Immigration Rules: Appendix FM — GEN.3.2 exceptional circumstances
- Form FLR(FP) — Family and private life applications in the UK
- Form FLR(HRO) — Other human rights claims
- Immigration and Asylum Bill: Article 8 reform factsheet — Proposed changes (Bill, not law)
General information only, current as at 19 November 2026. It is not legal advice and does not create a solicitor–client relationship. It reflects the law of England and Wales unless stated otherwise; Scotland and Northern Ireland have separate legal systems, and the law changes frequently. Check current official sources and take advice on the facts of your matter.



