TRW & Co · Asylum, deportation and detention
Humanitarian protection in the UK: serious harm, Article 3 and your rights

Humanitarian protection protects people who are not refugees but face a real risk of serious harm on return: execution, unlawful killing, torture or inhuman treatment, or indiscriminate violence in armed conflict. It is considered automatically when refugee status is refused, and claims made since 2 March 2026 lead to 30 months' leave.
Key pointHumanitarian protection is judged entirely on the lower "real risk" standard, so facts rejected in the refugee assessment must be looked at again. That second assessment is often decisive.
At a glance
Four kinds of serious harm
Death penalty, unlawful killing, torture or inhuman treatment, and indiscriminate violence in armed conflict.
No Convention reason needed
Unlike refugee status, the risk does not have to be linked to race, religion, nationality, politics or social group.
30-month leave
Claims made on or after 2 March 2026 lead to 30 months' permission; earlier claims to 5 years.
Medical cases
Health-based Article 3 claims usually lead to discretionary leave, not humanitarian protection.
Bill pending
The Immigration and Asylum Bill would merge refugee status and humanitarian protection.
Swipe or scroll →
Humanitarian protection: the short answer
Humanitarian protection is the UK's form of international protection for people who do not qualify as refugees but who would face a real risk of serious harm if returned to their country of origin. Serious harm means the death penalty or execution, unlawful killing, torture or inhuman or degrading treatment, or a serious threat to a civilian's life from indiscriminate violence in armed conflict.
The difference from refugee status is mainly about why the person is at risk. A refugee fears persecution for one of five Refugee Convention reasons: race, religion, nationality, political opinion or membership of a particular social group. Humanitarian protection covers serious harm without that link, for example a risk of execution for an ordinary crime, or a risk arising purely from the level of violence in a war zone.
There is no separate application. Every asylum claim is considered for refugee status first and, if that is refused, for humanitarian protection. This guide sets out the test as at November 2026, what a grant gives, and the reforms the government has announced.
The legal basis in Part 11 of the Immigration Rules
The rules are in Part 11 of the Immigration Rules. Paragraph 327EA defines a claim for humanitarian protection as a request for international protection based on a real risk of serious harm in the country of origin, where the person is unable or, because of that risk, unwilling to seek that country's protection. Paragraph 327EC says any such claim is treated as an asylum application and assessed for refugee status first.
Paragraph 339C then sets four conditions for a grant. The person must be in the UK or at a UK port; must not be a refugee; there must be substantial grounds for believing that, if returned, they would face a real risk of serious harm and be unable or unwilling to seek protection there; and they must not be excluded. The Home Office explains its approach in the humanitarian protection caseworker guidance, which has separate versions for claims lodged before and on or after 28 June 2022.
Valid claims must meet the same formal requirements as asylum claims: made in person, at a designated place, by someone who is not British, and particularised if the claimant is an adult. Our asylum claim process guide explains those steps.
What counts as serious harm
Paragraph 339CA defines serious harm exhaustively. The four categories below are the only ones that qualify; a risk of hardship, poverty or discrimination that falls short of them will not do, though it may support a different kind of claim.
Death penalty or execution
A real risk that the person will be sentenced to death or executed on return, whatever the alleged offence.
Unlawful killing
A real risk of being killed outside the law, for example by state agents or by actors the state cannot or will not control.
Torture or inhuman treatment
Torture or inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment in the country of origin, reflecting Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
Indiscriminate violence
A serious and individual threat to a civilian's life or person from indiscriminate violence in international or internal armed conflict.
Internal relocation applies to these categories as it does to refugee claims. Under paragraph 339O, protection will not be granted if there is a part of the country where the person would not face a real risk of serious harm and could reasonably be expected to stay. Sufficiency of state protection is also considered.
Humanitarian protection or refugee status?
Because the two statuses carry largely the same rights day to day, people often ask whether the label matters. It does, for three reasons: the standard of proof, the travel document, and the policy direction. The comparison below summarises the position as at November 2026.
Refugee status
- Needs a well-founded fear of persecution for a Refugee Convention reason.
- For claims made on or after 28 June 2022, section 32 of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022 applies a two-stage test, with some facts proved on the balance of probabilities.
- Holders receive a Refugee Convention travel document, unless compelling reasons of national security or public order apply.
- Excluded under Article 1F and Article 33(2) of the Refugee Convention.
Humanitarian protection
- Needs a real risk of serious harm, with no Convention reason required.
- Every element is judged to the lower "real risk" standard, meaning a reasonable degree of likelihood.
- Holders receive a travel document only if they cannot obtain a national passport, or in limited humanitarian cases.
- Excluded under paragraph 339D, which mirrors but is not identical to the Convention grounds.
The guidance tells caseworkers that because of the lower standard of proof, all material facts rejected in the refugee assessment must be reconsidered to the "real risk" standard before humanitarian protection is refused. In practice, that second look is where many claims succeed.

Article 3 claims: torture, prison conditions and medical cases
Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights prohibits torture and inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. It is absolute: it cannot be balanced against the public interest, whatever the person has done. The guidance says humanitarian protection will normally be granted where there is a real risk of treatment contrary to Article 3 that does not amount to persecution for a Convention reason.
Prison conditions
Systematically inhumane and life-threatening prison conditions breach Article 3. Even where general conditions do not reach that threshold, the guidance accepts that detention may breach Article 3 for a particular individual, depending on the likely length of detention, the facilities, and the person's age, gender, vulnerability and health. Where a prison sentence is discriminatory, refugee status may be the better analysis.
Dire humanitarian conditions
The Article 3 threshold is high. Citing the European Court of Human Rights in NA v UK and Sufi and Elmi v UK, the guidance accepts that general violence or a severe humanitarian situation can breach Article 3 only in the most extreme cases, considering the person's ability to meet basic needs such as food, hygiene and shelter, and their vulnerability.
Medical cases
Article 3 claims based on a medical condition and the lack of treatment on return are not usually eligible for humanitarian protection. Relying on the Court of Justice's decision in M'Bodj, the guidance says serious harm must come from the conduct of a third party, not from a naturally occurring illness combined with general shortcomings in a health system. Such cases are usually considered under the discretionary leave policy instead; see our human rights claim guide.
Indiscriminate violence in armed conflict
The fourth category of serious harm protects civilians caught up in conflict. The guidance applies the test from the Court of Appeal in QD (Iraq) v SSHD [2009] EWCA Civ 620: is there in the country, or a material part of it, such a high level of indiscriminate violence that substantial grounds exist for believing that a person would, solely by being present there, face a real risk to their life or person?
- Civilians only. The test protects genuine non-combatants, which can include former combatants who have genuinely and permanently renounced armed activity.
- A material part. The assessment focuses on the home area or a proposed place of relocation, so internal relocation must also be considered.
- Level, not label. What matters is the level of violence and the risk to civilians, not how the conflict is classified.
- The sliding scale. The more a person is specifically affected by personal characteristics, such as age, disability, ethnicity or perceived collaboration, the lower the level of violence needed.
Country guidance cases from the Upper Tribunal, and the Home Office's country policy and information notes, are central evidence. They change as conditions change, so a claim must be built on the most recent material.
In conflict cases, the question is not whether there is a war, but whether this person would face a real risk to life simply by going home.
Exclusion from humanitarian protection
Under paragraph 339D, a person is excluded from humanitarian protection if there are serious reasons for considering that they have committed a crime against peace, a war crime or a crime against humanity; committed a serious non-political crime outside the UK before being admitted as a protected person; been guilty of acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations; been convicted of a particularly serious crime and is a danger to the community; or is a danger to the security of the UK.
A "particularly serious crime" is defined by section 72 of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002, as amended in 2022, as one punished by at least 12 months' imprisonment. There is a rebuttable presumption that such a person is a danger to the community, and the guidance requires the Home Office to give an opportunity to rebut it before excluding anyone on this ground.
Exclusion from humanitarian protection does not permit removal to a real risk of Article 3 ill-treatment. Where a person is excluded but an Article 3 risk is established, the guidance requires caseworkers to consider restricted leave instead. Our deportation solicitors deal with these cases regularly.
What a grant of humanitarian protection gives you
The length of leave depends on when the claim was made. Paragraphs 339QB and 339QBA of Part 11 set the rules, and the change on 2 March 2026 is significant.
| Claim or further submissions made | Leave granted | Route to settlement |
|---|---|---|
| On or before 1 March 2026 | At least 5 years | Indefinite leave under Appendix Settlement Protection after 5 years; no fee |
| On or after 2 March 2026 | At least 30 months, renewable | Not yet set; government proposes a "core protection" pathway (announced policy) |
| Unaccompanied child, or would have been but for turning 18 | At least 5 years | As for the relevant claim date |
People with humanitarian protection can work without restriction, because paragraph 344B prevents employment conditions being imposed. Dependants who meet paragraph 349 are granted leave for the same period on the same conditions. Further leave should be applied for in the last 28 days of current permission.
Family members
The refugee family reunion route under Appendix Family Reunion (Sponsors with Protection) has been suspended to new applications since 4 September 2025. Partners and children of protection holders must now apply under Appendix FM, with its fees and financial requirements. Under HC 259, a partner joining a sponsor with 30-month protection leave is granted leave in line with the sponsor's remaining leave. See our refugee family reunion guide.
Settlement
GOV.UK's settlement page says people with protection status can apply for indefinite leave after 5 years in the UK, with no fee. That reflects the position for people whose claims were made on or before 1 March 2026. For later claims, settlement terms depend on the earned settlement reforms, which are not yet in the Rules.

Revocation, cessation and appeal rights
Humanitarian protection must be revoked if the circumstances that led to the grant have ceased to exist or changed so much that protection is no longer required, if the person should have been or is excluded, or if facts decisive to the grant were misrepresented or omitted (paragraphs 339G to 339GD). Any leave can then be curtailed or cancelled. On cessation, the Home Office must consider whether the change is significant and non-temporary enough that the person no longer faces a real risk of serious harm.
Under section 82 of the 2002 Act, a refusal of a protection claim carries a right of appeal. The guidance confirms that this includes a decision that refuses refugee status but grants humanitarian protection, so a person granted humanitarian protection can still appeal to try to obtain refugee status. A decision to revoke protection status also carries an appeal, which must be brought from outside the UK if the decision was made while the person was abroad. Appeals go to the First-tier Tribunal.
Proposed reforms: core protection and earned settlement
The government has announced, and in part legislated for, a significant reshaping of protection. It is important to separate what is in force from what is proposed.
- In force since 2 March 2026: protection leave of 30 months for new claims, instead of 5 years, with 5 years kept for unaccompanied children.
- Announced policy (November 2025): the "Restoring Order and Control" statement proposed a "core protection" status with 30-month renewable leave and a 20-year route to settlement.
- Announced policy (November 2026): the earned settlement response (CP 1707) sets Core Protection at 20 years to settlement and a Protection Work and Study route at 10 years, with extra time for illegal entry unless Article 31 of the Refugee Convention protects the person. Detail and commencement are not yet published.
- Bill (not yet law): the Immigration and Asylum Bill would merge refugee status and humanitarian protection into a single protection status and end "upgrade appeals" (Home Office factsheet). It is now in the House of Lords.
If the Bill passes in its current form, the distinction between refugee status and humanitarian protection described in this guide would largely disappear for future grants, and so would the right to appeal a grant of humanitarian protection in order to obtain refugee status. Until then, the current law applies.
Pitfalls in humanitarian protection claims
Treating humanitarian protection as a fallback only
Because the claim is assessed for refugee status first, representations often focus only on the Convention reason. Evidence of serious harm that does not depend on a Convention reason should be developed in its own right.
Relying on general country evidence alone
In indiscriminate violence cases, generic reports rarely meet the test. Evidence of personal characteristics that increase risk under the sliding scale, and of conditions in the home area, is what moves a case.
Framing a medical claim as humanitarian protection
Health-based Article 3 claims are normally considered under discretionary leave, which carries different leave periods and a fee for settlement. Framing the claim correctly from the start saves time.
Ignoring exclusion risks
A conviction of 12 months or more triggers the section 72 presumption. Evidence of rehabilitation and of low risk should be ready before the decision, not after.
Missing the further leave window
Applications for further permission should be made in the last 28 days of current leave. Late applications can leave a gap in status.
A worked example and next steps
Example (hypothetical): a woman flees a region where government forces and an armed group are shelling residential areas. She is not politically active and does not belong to any targeted group, so the Home Office refuses refugee status. Her representatives argue that the level of indiscriminate violence in her home province meets the QD (Iraq) test, and that as a single mother with a disabled child she is more exposed under the sliding scale.
They also show that the only other route to the capital passes through armed checkpoints, so internal relocation is not reasonable. The Home Office grants humanitarian protection. Because her claim was made after 2 March 2026, she receives 30 months' permission to stay, can work immediately and must apply for further leave in the last 28 days. She can also appeal the refusal of refugee status if there is evidence of a Convention reason.
Refugee status
The Convention test, standard of proof and what a grant gives.
Read the guideAsylumThe substantive interview
How to prepare evidence of serious harm for interview.
Read the guideAsylumFresh claims
Further submissions when circumstances change.
Read the guideSettlementEarned settlement
The announced settlement reforms and what they mean.
Read the guide

If you have been refused refugee status, granted humanitarian protection or told your protection may be revoked, book a consultation with our asylum solicitors to review the decision and your options.
Frequently asked questions
01Can I apply for humanitarian protection without claiming asylum?
No. A humanitarian protection claim is treated as an asylum claim and must meet the same validity requirements, including being made in person at a designated place. It is considered if refugee status is refused.
02Can I travel abroad with humanitarian protection?
You can apply for a Home Office travel document if you cannot obtain your national passport. GOV.UK warns that even after settlement, travelling back to the country you sought asylum from can cost you your indefinite leave, so take advice before any such trip.
03Can I claim benefits with humanitarian protection?
The Home Office guidance says temporary permission on a protection route gives access to the benefits and services a person may need. Eligibility for each benefit depends on its own rules, so check the specific benefit before applying.
04Is humanitarian protection the same as discretionary leave?
No. Discretionary leave is granted outside the Rules in limited cases, such as serious medical conditions, and has a different route to settlement: GOV.UK says 10 years for leave first granted from 9 July 2012, with a fee.
05What happens if conditions improve in my country?
The Home Office can revoke humanitarian protection if the change is significant and non-temporary so that you no longer face a real risk of serious harm. Revocation carries a right of appeal.
06Can my children get humanitarian protection too?
Children who meet the dependant rules are granted leave in line with the main applicant. A child with separate protection needs should have their own claim considered.
Sources and official materials
- Immigration Rules Part 11: asylum (paragraphs 327EA, 339C to 339QBA) — Definition, serious harm, exclusion and leave periods
- Granting humanitarian protection: caseworker guidance — Home Office approach to serious harm, Article 3 and exclusion
- European Convention on Human Rights — Article 3 prohibition of torture
- Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002, section 72 — Particularly serious crime presumption
- Indefinite leave to remain for protection status holders (GOV.UK) — Settlement after 5 years for earlier grants
- Immigration and Asylum Bill: core protection factsheet — Proposed single protection status (not yet law)
General information only, current as at 19 November 2026. It is not legal advice and does not create a solicitor–client relationship. It reflects the law of England and Wales unless stated otherwise; Scotland and Northern Ireland have separate legal systems, and the law changes frequently. Check current official sources and take advice on the facts of your matter.



